Narrenes skip dummet seg ut

Alan M. Dershowitz

The recent attempts by anti-Israel extre­mists to break Israel’s naval blockage of Gaza and to flood Israel’s air­ports with trouble­ma­kers have failed.

The ships of fools, kna­ves hypocri­tes, bigots, and sup­por­ters of ter­ro­rism that tried to sail from Gre­ece have now appa­rently been run aground. Most of the hard-left extre­mists have gone home following a deci­sion by the Greek govern­ment to pre­vent the boats from lea­ving Greek ports. And those who tried to flood Israel’s air­ports are being deported. The resul­ting fiasco, which was desig­ned to discre­dit Israel, has succe­e­ded only in discre­di­ting the Israel bashers on the boats and pla­nes by expos­ing their true purpose.

The alleged pur­pose of the ships was to feed the star­ving Arabs of Gaza. The pro­blem is that the Arabs of Gaza are not star­ving. Nor are they in need of out­side help.

Accor­ding to repor­ting by The New York Times, Gaza has been thri­ving recently. Luxury hotels are being built; sto­res are stocked with food; beaches are fil­led with child­ren; and life is far bet­ter than in neigh­bo­ring Al Arish, which is across the bor­der in Egypt.

In fact, accor­ding to news reports, the resi­dents of Gaza are far bet­ter off than the resi­dents of many Arab areas in the Middle East. Medi­cal care is bet­ter, infant mor­ta­lity is lower, longe­vity is hig­her, emp­loy­ment is increas­ing, cars are plen­ti­ful, food is more avai­lable and the qua­lity of water and air is hig­her. The Gross Natio­nal Pro­duct has risen dra­ma­ti­cally over the past year.

To be sure, the citizens of Gaza do not have free­dom of speech, free­dom of reli­gion, free­dom of the press, the right to dis­sent or the abi­lity to join poli­ti­cal par­ties that are out of favor. These limi­ta­tions are the fault of Hamas, not of Israel.

Indeed, the only Arabs in the region whose lives, in every respect, are bet­ter than those who live in Gaza, are the citizens of the West Bank, which is con­trolled by the Pale­sti­nian Aut­hority rat­her than Hamas.

So if the fools on the ships were really inte­re­sted in hel­ping Arabs who are truly in need of food, medi­cine and other pro­vi­sions, they would set sail for ports in Egypt, Syria, Leba­non and other areas of the Middle East. But these hypocri­tes have no inte­rest in hel­ping the down­trod­den. Their only inte­rest is in dele­gi­ti­mi­zing the Jewish state of Israel.

Many of those on the ships actually sup­port the most oppres­sive regi­mes in the Middle East, such as the Syrian regime, which mur­ders its civi­li­ans in cold blood; the Ira­nian regime, which bru­tally suppres­ses dis­sent; Hez­bol­lah which mur­ders its poli­ti­cal oppo­nents; and Hamas which sub­ju­ga­tes women and exe­cutes gays.

Most of these “human rights acti­vists” have no his­tory of sup­por­ting human rights elsewhere in the world and many have records of sup­por­ting the worst abu­sers of human rights. The list of those on the boats is a dis­ho­nor role of human wrongs, bla­tant hypocrisy, and double standards.

A com­mon virus among many on these ships is a hatred for Jews, the Jewish state, Ame­rica, and the West. Some are self-haters, because they them­sel­ves are Jews, Israe­lis or Western­ers. Others are Arabs who can­not abide the notion of the Jewish state, regard­less of its size or bor­ders, any­where in the Middle East.

I am aware of none who applies a single stan­dard of human rights to all countries in the world and priori­tizes his or her acti­vities in order of the serious­ness of the human rights violations.

These sea and air efforts to dele­gi­ti­mize Israel by apply­ing a double stan­dard to its actions have fai­led. There will be others. They will include efforts to incite mobs to cross the bor­der into Israel through Syria, Leba­non, and Jor­dan. The goal will be to pro­voke Israel into over­reac­tion. Every govern­ment in the world has the right to pre­vent the law vio­la­tors from ille­gally ente­ring their coun­try, but only Israel is condemned for its efforts to do so.

There will also be efforts in Sep­tem­ber to use the machinery of the Uni­ted Nations, most par­ti­cu­larly of the Gene­ral Assem­bly, to dele­gi­ti­mize Israel. These efforts will include a vote to rec­og­nize the Pale­sti­nian state wit­hout requi­ring the Pale­sti­ni­ans to sit down and try to nego­tiate a real peace with Israel.

It will also include efforts by the noto­rious Human Rights Coun­cil of the Uni­ted Nations to condemn Israel for vir­tually eve­rything it’s done since it came into exist­ence 63 years ago. None of these will succeed but they will encourage Israel’s ene­mies to become even more intransi­gent, while at the same time dis­coura­ging them from making the kinds of com­pro­mi­ses that Israel is wil­ling to make in the inte­rest of peace.

Those who really believe in uni­ver­sal human rights applied equally to all nations throug­hout the world should condemn these efforts to single out Israel for dele­gi­ti­mi­zing. They should join with other true sup­por­ters of human rights in priori­ti­zing the human wrongs throug­hout the world and seeking to con­front them by deman­ding the appli­ca­tion of a single standard.

When a pro­per stan­dard is uni­ver­sally applied, Israel’s record on human rights shi­nes in compa­ri­son with the records of nations and groups sup­ported by the fools and hypocri­tes on these boats and planes.

Opp­rin­ne­lig:
Ships and Pla­nes of Fools Pick Wrong Tar­get
by Alan M. Der­showitz
July 11, 2011 at 4:20 pm

http://www.hudson-ny.org/2260/ships-planes-of-fools


Om du ikke følger Document på sosiale media kan du følge oss på e-post.

Donere engangsbeløp?Kan du forplikte deg til fast betaling?

Penger kan også doneres til kontonummer 15030249981.

Leserkommentarer på Document er gjenstand for moderering, som ikke skjer kontinuerlig og under enhver omstendighet ikke om natten. Vi ønsker en respektfull tone uten personangrep, sleivete språk eller flammende retorikk. Vis særlig nøkternhet når temaet er følsomt. Begrenset redigering av skjemmende detaljer kan finne sted. Skriv til debatt@document.no dersom du ikke forstår hvorfor en kommentar uteblir. Se her for nybegynnerhjelp.