Frihet og integrering i Tyskland

Nina Hjerpset-Østlie

Chris­top­her Caldwell

When Wolf­gang Schäuble con­vo­ked a multi-year “Islam Con­fe­rence” in 2006 to ease rela­tions between Ger­man society and its Mus­lim minority, the interior minis­ter made a state­ment – “Islam is a part of Ger­many” – that was viewed as a ground­breaking and generous concession.

Today it looks more like a state­ment of the obvious. At the final ses­sion of the con­fe­rence on Thurs­day, the­Fe­deral Office for Migra­tion and Refugees (BAMF) released a study on “Mus­lim Life in Ger­many”. It found that there are vastly more Mus­lims in Ger­many than most spec­ia­lists and pun­dits had assu­med. Where most esti­ma­tes held the Mus­lim popu­la­tion at around 3m, the more com­pre­hen­sive BAMF study places it around 4m, and pos­sibly as high as 4.3m. That means Mus­lims make up not 4 per cent of the popu­la­tion, but 6 per cent.

Does this mat­ter? Of course it does. The new num­bers are grist to the mill of those who say the aut­hori­ties have not been straight with them about the scope of immi­gra­tion. More impor­tant, the size of a com­mu­nity affects a country’s options for inte­gra­ting it. The big­ger it is, the har­der it is.

Against this, the BAMF study offers one basic rea­son for opti­mism: diver­sity. We should think not of a mono­lith of mil­lions of like-minded newco­mers but of a mosaic of com­mu­nities, 10,000 here, 10,000 there. If Germany’s Mus­lims can­not agree among them­sel­ves, then how, in the end, can they develop a loyalty or alle­gi­ance to any­thing other than the Ger­man state? The multi-facetedness of Ger­man Mus­lim life is an impli­cit rebut­tal of the sense that Mus­lims are “taking over”.

But there is a pro­blem. Rela­tive to that of other immi­grant countries, Mus­lim life in Ger­many is not diverse. Almost two-thirds of Ger­man Mus­lims (2.6m) are of Tur­kish descent. No simi­larly pre­pon­derant national-origin or lin­gui­s­tic group exists among, say, Sweden’s or Italy’s immi­grants. A third of Germany’s Mus­lims live in one state, North Rhine-Westphalia, and 98 per cent live in the for­mer West Ger­man Länder.

What is more, Germany’s immi­grants of Mus­lim back­ground are reli­gious in a way that nati­ves are not. Accor­ding to the BAMF study, 87 per cent describe them­sel­ves as eit­her very reli­gious or rat­her reli­gious; 81 per cent obey Isla­mic die­tary laws and 31 per cent of women wear the heads­carf. Only 4 per cent describe them­sel­ves as not reli­gious at all.

No Mus­lim com­mu­nities diverge much from this reli­gio­sity, though the report draws com­fort from the fact that Ira­ni­ans (70 per cent belie­vers) are not quite so reli­gious. Mus­lims, whether they are one com­mu­nity or seve­ral, have cer­tain shared values they can be expec­ted to pur­sue – and are entit­led to pur­sue – in the pub­lic sphere. A lot of impor­tant poli­ti­cal ques­tions today, from gay mar­riage to sexual edu­ca­tion, revolve around how deeply reli­gious prin­cip­les ought to inform pub­lic law. How diverse, poli­ti­cally speak­ing, will Ger­man Mus­lims be?

While Mr Schäuble’s Islam Con­fe­rence can be applau­ded as a ges­ture of wel­come, its focus on the diver­sity of Mus­lim com­mu­nities is beset with con­tra­dic­tions. If Islam in Ger­many is as diverse as the BAMF report says, then why is a big natio­nal ini­tia­tive the right way to deal with it? And what is the desi­red outcome?

A con­clave such as the Islam con­fe­rence tends to ele­vate the invi­tees to semi-official sta­tus as com­mu­nity repre­sen­ta­ti­ves. This gives them a strong incen­tive to forge a “Mus­lim com­mu­nity” where none exi­sted. The les­son of deca­des of such con­fe­ren­ces from the US civil rights move­ment is that they make the groups they deal with less diverse.

Necla Kelek, the Turkish-born socio­lo­gist and essay­ist who was a mem­ber of the Islam Con­fe­rence, belie­ves that the fai­lure of immi­grants and their descen­dants to inte­grate is “becoming the cen­tral pro­blem of the entire society”. She cites some asto­nish­ing num­bers about immi­grants’ tendency to marry wit­hin their eth­nic group. Only 8 per cent of Tur­kish men who grow up in Ger­many marry Ger­man women and only 3 per cent of Tur­kish women who grow up in Ger­many marry Ger­man men. In a speech last month, she placed the blame on the Mus­lim exten­ded family. “What a lot of people here in Ger­many view as a model for security and mutual care,” she said, “often comes at the price of indi­vi­dual auto­nomy.” Free­dom means free­dom to prac­tise Islam.

We should lis­ten very care­fully to such descrip­tions as Ms Kelek’s. A com­mon ste­reo­type about the par­ti­cu­lar dif­fi­cul­ties of assi­mi­la­ting Mus­lim immi­grants is that they come from a repressed cul­ture and have trouble get­ting used to western free­doms. But that is not it. The Mus­lim way of life in Ger­many, Kelek warns, rests on a vision of free­dom, dif­fe­rent though it is from Ger­mans’. Fifteen per cent of Mus­lim parents, the BAMF found, keep their daugh­ters out of sexual-education clas­ses. What should be done about that? The report recom­mends Überze­u­gungs­ar­beit – an effort to con­vince tra­ditio­na­lists of the error of their ways. Should the state com­pel fami­lies to send their daugh­ters to sex-ed? If so, who has the pro­blem with liberty?

This is why the size of immi­grant com­mu­nities is impor­tant. It is not that Mus­lim efforts to Isla­mise local insti­tu­tions, where they occur, are fana­ti­cal. It is that they are natu­ral, sen­sible and in line with western democracy. Most people want a society that reflects their values. The pro­blems with Islam in the west are somet­hing more com­pli­cated than pro­blems of oppres­sion. They are pro­blems of freedom.

The wri­ter is a senior edi­tor at The Weekly Stan­dard. His book, ‘Reflections on the Revo­lu­tion in Europe: Immi­gra­tion, Islam and the West’, was pub­lis­hed in May.

Opp­rin­ne­lig 4. juli 2009

Denne saken er som man ser av eldre dato. Red. har et antall saker lig­gende av høy kva­li­tet, men som av en eller annen grunn er blitt lig­gende. De for­tje­ner å komme til leser­nes kjenn­skap og vi vil pub­li­sere dem før sommeren.




Om du ikke følger Document på sosiale media kan du følge oss på e-post.

Donere engangsbeløp?Kan du forplikte deg til fast betaling?

Penger kan også doneres til kontonummer 15030249981. Du kan også støtte oss ved å kjøpe bøker eller varer.

Leserkommentarer på Document er gjenstand for moderering, som ikke skjer kontinuerlig og under enhver omstendighet ikke om natten. Vi ønsker en respektfull tone uten personangrep, sleivete språk eller flammende retorikk. Vis særlig nøkternhet når temaet er følsomt. Begrenset redigering av skjemmende detaljer kan finne sted. Skriv til debatt@document.no dersom du ikke forstår hvorfor en kommentar uteblir. Se her for nybegynnerhjelp.